by Scott Faulds
In recent years, cities across the UK have begun to explore how they can best capitalize on technological advances to help to create places which operate in a more efficient and sustainable way. The concept of the smart city is relatively wide-ranging; in basic terms, it can be described as an urban area that uses various forms of technology to gather data that can then be analysed to reveal insights about how citizens engage with their environment. The advent of smart city technology, and its ability to be installed in numerous forms across existing city infrastructure, means that it can often be challenging to assess and understand the success of its deployment.
A recent article published in Emerald Open Research – UK smart cities present and future: An analysis of British smart cities through current and emerging technologies and practices – aims to address this issue by providing an overview of the progress of 26 UK cities which are currently deploying smart city technology. The article attempts to analyse the current state of the smart city roll-out and evaluate the types of technology that are being installed. As the concept of the smart city is one that is fluid, each city’s implementation of the technology can vary, as can the success of the integration.
Designing a smart city evaluation framework
In order to understand the current state of the smart city rollout, the article employs a framework that can be used to assess what types of technology have been deployed and the current state of the deployment.
The following categories are used to classify smart city technology:
Essential services – 5G, full-fibre internet, Internet of Things
Smart Transportation – digital ticket booking, smart cards, electric vehicle charging points
Broad Spectrum – retrofitting buildings, digital social inclusion schemes, hackathons
Business Ecosystem – innovation hubs, co-spaces, tech entrepreneurial networks
Open Data Provider – urban dashboards, urban models, big data
The state of the rollout of smart technology is evaluated on the following scale:
0 – no measures underway
1 – public announcement of plan
2 – study in advanced stages/detailed roadmap
3 – testing/trials
4 – installation of technology on smaller scales
5 – fully established and integrated into the city
By analysing relevant documents/news reports and applying the aforementioned framework, the article finds that the most common type of smart city infrastructure installed in cities across the UK is technology which enables the collection of open data. In particular, a group known as Smart Cities Scotland has been found to have one of the most advanced implementations of open data technology. This is due to the creation of an open source data platform which allows anyone to access the data collected and develop smart city technology that directly responds to the needs of these cities.
Approaches to deploying smart city technology
Through the application of the framework, London and Bristol were discovered to be the cities in the UK with the most advanced implementation of smart city technology; this was largely due to the widespread use of all of the categories. However, the authors also suggest that the steps taken by smaller cities, such as Dundee and Peterborough, are often of more interest, as they clearly show the two prevailing approaches to the implementation of smart city technology.
The approach taken by Dundee is one in which cities select one or two smart city categories and focus on getting these technologies to become fully integrated and widespread. For example, Dundee has chosen to focus on the integration of open data (via Smart Cities Scotland) and smart transportation technologies, in a bid to create a fully sustainable transport network. An in-depth focus on these areas has enabled Dundee to become a leader in the switch to zero-carbon transport, through the creation of the Mobility Innovation Living Lab and the electrification of 20% of the local taxi fleet. However, whilst the implementation of open data and smart transportation technology places Dundee as a leader in these categories, their implementation of essential services or broad spectrum technology is poor when compared to other cities in the UK.
Peterborough, on the other hand, has taken an almost diametric approach and is focused on deploying a broad variety of smart city technologies, that will allow them to reach their goal of becoming a gigabit city and establishing a circular economy. The city has deployed a variety of online platforms, designed to engage citizens and business alike, to come together and share resources that will allow Peterborough to support and empower everyone in the city to minimize waste.
The future of the Smart City
As well as analysing the current state of the smart city rollout, the article also discusses the future of the smart city and sets out its expectations for the next decade. A key theme discussed is the concept of a more connected city, powered through 5G and increased network capacity, which will allow for city infrastructure to communicate and easily respond to changes in the way citizens are engaging with the urban environment. However, the article concludes that we are unlikely to see any major visual changes to our cities, apart from an increase in electric vehicles and their accompanying infrastructure. A great deal of the smart city technology currently being deployed in UK cities tends to occur behind the scenes, but, these changes will allow councils to harness the power of data to make better decisions about the future day-to-day workings of our cities.
To conclude, this article provides one of the first overviews of the state of the smart city rollout across the UK, allowing for a comparative analysis of the different approaches cities have taken to implement various forms of smart city technology. Establishing a framework of how to evaluate this progress allows those interested in smart city technology to assess which smart city technologies are most prevalent and which cities are at a more advanced stage of the rollout.
In short, this article will be extremely informative for anyone with an interest in learning more about smart city technology and its deployment in the UK.
Articles on smart cities on The Knowledge Exchange blog
- Smart cities aim to make urban life more efficient – but for citizens’ sake they need to slow down
- How a smart canal and a sponge city could regenerate North Glasgow
- The ‘Netflix of transportation’ – could MaaS be the future of urban mobility?
Follow us on Twitter to see which topics are interesting our research team
The Knowledge Exchange remains open for business and continues to provide current awareness and enquiries services to our clients. If you have any questions, please get in touch.
Pingback: One-minute cities could put the world on your doorstep | The Knowledge Exchange Blog
Pingback: Are smart cities at risk from hackers? | The Knowledge Exchange Blog
Pingback: Cities on the edge: edge computing and the development of smart cities | The Knowledge Exchange Blog
Pingback: The year of living differently: reviewing The Knowledge Exchange blog in 2020 | The Knowledge Exchange Blog
Pingback: Connecting the future: what is 5G? | The Knowledge Exchange Blog
Pingback: Changing governnment, changing society: what now for public innovation? | The Knowledge Exchange Blog