Throughout October, a series of events to promote diversity and equality will take place as part of Black History Month. Although there are many achievements to celebrate, it is an unfortunate fact that many people in the UK today still experience disadvantage due to the colour of their skin.
Over the summer, reports by the Equality and Human Rights Commission (EHRC) and the UN Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination (CERD), found that racial inequality in the UK was ‘worryingly high’.
In its biggest ever review of race inequality in the UK, the EHRC concluded that:
“while for certain people life has become fairer over the past five years, for others progress has stalled and for some– in particular young Black people – life on many fronts has got worse.”
Audit of racial disparities announced
The government responded quickly by announcing an audit of racial disparities in public services. It promises to ‘shine a light on injustices as never before’.
From summer 2017, Whitehall departments will be required to identify and publish information annually on outcomes for people of different backgrounds in areas such as health, education, childcare, welfare, employment, skills and criminal justice.
As well as enabling the public to check how their race affects the way they are treated by public services, the data is also intended to help force services to improve.
The audit is being called ‘unprecedented’ – and it certainly is – up until now, public services in the UK have not systematically gathered data for the purposes of racial comparison. Indeed, according to the FT, very few countries, if any at all, currently produce racial impact audits.
‘Worryingly high’ levels of racial inequality
The audit will have its work cut out. The review by the EHRC found that, compared to their White counterparts, people from ethnic minorities were more likely to be:
- on low wages and/or in insecure employment
- excluded from school
- less qualified
- living in poverty
- living in substandard and/or overcrowded accommodation
- experiencing mental and physical health problems
- in the criminal justice system
- stopped and searched by police
- a victim of hate crime
- a victim of homicide
Similarly, the CERD findings into how well the UK is meeting its obligations under the International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination (ICERD) raised serious concerns about the level of institutional racism in UK public services. Omar Khan, of the Runnymede Trust, suggested that the findings would ‘embarrass the UK on the world stage’.
Longstanding inequalities in access to services, the quality of care received and patients’ health outcomes were criticised, as was the over-representation of persons belonging to ethnic minorities in psychiatric institutions.
The committee echoed the EHRC’s concerns regarding higher unemployment rates and the concentration of persons belonging to ethnic minorities in insecure and low-paid work. They also criticised the use of discriminatory recruitment practices by employers.
In education, there were concerns regarding reports of racist bullying and harassment in schools, and the lack of balanced teaching about the history of the British Empire and colonialism, particularly with regard to slavery.
The committee also concluded that there had been an outbreak of xenophobia and discrimination against ethnic minorities, particularly since the EU referendum campaign. Indeed, the rise in post-Brexit racial tensions has been widely acknowledged.
Equal to the task?
Although the audit has been welcomed by many, including the EHRC, others have raised concern about the extent to which it will tackle the root of the problem. Danny Dorling, of Oxford University, remains sceptical, stating that “within two or three years every single one of these audits is forgotten”.
Some have noted that in order to be effective, the audit will also have to capture outcomes for migrant families, and for poorer White people, who also suffer from discrimination and disadvantage. Others, including Labour’s Angela Rayner, shadow equalities minister, have noted that there is a ‘huge gap’ in the review as it would not include the private sector.
The EHRC have called upon the government to create “a comprehensive, coordinated and long-term strategy to achieve race equality, with stretching new targets to improve opportunities and deliver clear and measurable outcomes.”
Certainly, the data produced by the racial equality audit may well provide some basis for the establishment of such targets.
So while this October there is cause for celebrating the progress made so far, the findings of the EHRC and the CERD underline just how entrenched and far-reaching race inequality remains. As the EHRC states:
“We must tackle this with the utmost urgency if we are to heal the divisions in our society and prevent an escalation of tensions between our communities.”
Follow us on Twitter to see what developments in public and social policy are interesting our research team.