The Scottish Government’s Climate Change Plan Update is due to be published this month (December 2020), after being postponed from April due to the coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic. The plan will provide an update on the Scottish Government’s Climate Change Plan, reflecting the new targets set out in the Climate Change (Emissions Reduction Targets) (Scotland) Act 2019, with the overall aim of reducing Scotland’s emissions of all greenhouse gases to net-zero by 2045.
In the face of the climate emergency, the target is both admirable and ambitious. Achieving it will require input from all sectors of the economy and society – from energy, transport, infrastructure to skills, training and innovation.
A recent series of webinars held by Partners in Planning looked at the ways in which town planning could help play its part by embedding nature-based solutions and green infrastructure planning into the planning process.
In this blog we look at three innovative projects that were highlighted. They illustrate some of the varied ways in which planning can contribute towards the Scottish Government’s net zero targets and address the wider climate emergency.
Building with Nature: green infrastructure benchmark
Encouraging developers to incorporate green infrastructure and nature-based solutions into new developments is a key challenge, particularly if there is a perception that it may be more time consuming and/or costly to do so.
Building with Nature is a set of wellbeing standards built around the ‘3 Ws’ – water, wildlife and wellbeing. The standards go beyond statutory requirements, bringing together evidence, guidance and good practice to provide something akin to a ‘how to’ guide for creating places that benefit both people and nature. The standards are free to access and use, and there is also a paid-for accreditation scheme, with three levels of achievement – design, good, and excellent.
As well as reducing carbon emissions, the standards aim to help support biodiversity, promote flood resilience and support wellbeing through the provision of green space that is both inclusive and accessible to everyone, regardless of age or disability.
The standards are entirely voluntary but many local authorities are now beginning to either refer developers to Building with Nature or incorporate them as requirements in their own plans.
Plans themselves can also become accredited. Indeed, West Dunbartonshire Council’s Local Development Plan 2, published in August 2020, is the first Building with Nature accredited policy document, achieving the ‘excellent’ rating.
Green-blue roofs – Meadowbank, Edinburgh
One way that developers can incorporate nature-based solutions into their developments is through the use of green-blue roofs. Green-blue roofs can provide a range of benefits for both people and nature – including surface water management, urban cooling, as well as providing habitats for wildlife and opportunities for people to access nature in the urban environment.
At present, there is no mandatory policy for green roof infrastructure in Scotland, thus while developers may be aware of the benefits that they have, many do not incorporate them into their plans due concerns about their impact on scheme costs and viability.
These concerns have been addressed in a study of the viability of incorporating green-blue roofs into a mixed-used development at the former Meadowbank Stadium site in Edinburgh, conducted by Collective Architecture on behalf of NatureScot (previously called Scottish Natural Heritage).
The study highlights the varied range of green-blue roof options available to developers – all with different costs, levels of maintenance, building requirements etc. Some are suitable for public access whereas others are not. Blue-green roofs are a combination of both green roofs and blue roofs – where rainwater is retained rather than drained (as with a typical green roof) and released in a controlled manner.
Overall, green-blue roofs were found to be a viable option for the Meadowbank development, freeing up space that might otherwise be used for ground-based SUDS (sustainable drainage systems), and offering a range of potential wellbeing and community benefits. Blue-green roofs did cause a small uplift in roofing costs. However, as a proportion of the overall construction costs, these were minimal, coming in at around £350 per dwelling.
Retrofitting green infrastructure – Queensland Gardens, Cardonald, Glasgow
If our towns and cities are to become truly carbon neutral, then there will also be a need to retrofit green infrastructure into existing developments. One such example of retrofitting is Queensland Court and Gardens – a partnership between Southside Housing Association and Glasgow City Council to retrofit green infrastructure designs into two multi-storey tower blocks and the surrounding land in Cardonald, Glasgow.
The project is part of the wider Green Infrastructure Strategic Intervention (GISI) programme, which as well as contributing to the ultimate goal of achieving a net zero carbon society, seeks to demonstrate how green infrastructure can be used to address some of the key issues faced in urban areas – from declining economic growth, social inequalities, pollution, flooding, noise, multiple deprivation, health problems and limited biodiversity.
One of the key issues facing the outdoor space at Queensland Gardens is excess surface water, which renders much of the space unusable. As such, the project has also received funding from 10,000 Raingardens for Scotland. It plans to turn the rainwater run-off from the tower blocks into a feature that is incorporated into the gardens. It also plans to expand the current parking facilities, create a shared community green space, and enhance the currently very limited play space for children and young people.
Both the Queensland Gardens and the Meadowbank site developments will be assessed against the Building with Nature standards.
Green infrastructure as part of the green recovery
The coronavirus pandemic has brought into sharp focus the importance of having local green spaces that are both easily accessible and inclusive of all ages and disabilities. It highlighted the importance of nature to the health of society and the world more broadly, along with the urgent need to address climate change.
It also demonstrated that it is possible to create and implement innovative solutions to global crises on a tight timescale, when both the need and will exist. There are strong calls now for a ‘green recovery’, and it is expected that the imminent Climate Change Plan Update will feature this concept heavily. Indeed Scotland has already made a number of commitments for a green recovery as part of their 2020/21 Programme for Government, and the findings of the recent Green Recovery Inquiry reinforce its importance.
As the above examples show, embedding green infrastructure and nature-based solutions into the planning system is one way to help achieve Scotland’s goal of becoming net zero by 2045. By doing so, we can create places and spaces that benefit not only ourselves, but also society and the planet.
Read some of our other blogs related to the environment:
- ‘Bending the Curve’ of biodiversity loss – could Covid-19 be the catalyst for change?
- Build back better: is now the time for Green New Deals? – Part 1
- Build back better: is now the time for Green New Deals? – Part 2
Follow us on Twitter to find out what topic areas are interesting our research team.